Tent City Eviction

September 25, 2002

Debates of the Ontario Legislature – Hansard
Wednesday, September 25, 2002

AFFORDABLE HOUSING

                    Mr Howard Hampton (Kenora-Rainy River): My question is to the Deputy

                    Premier. I would say to the Deputy Premier, yesterday was a very shameful

                    day in Ontario. It was a shameful day because in effect homeless people,

                    some of the poorest, most vulnerable people in this province, essentially had

                    the police sent out to round them up. Your government's way of dealing with

                    a social problem is simply to send in the police and turn them out.

 

                    Minister, it's pretty clear that there is a big problem growing, that there is not

                    enough affordable housing, not in this city, not in many other cities. We have

                    put forward a plan that would allow us to build not only 8,000 units of

                    affordable housing each year, but 2,800 units of supportive housing for

                    people who need a hand up. What is your plan for affordable housing, or do

                    you have a plan for affordable housing in this province? Or do you just send

                    in the police?

 

                    Hon Elizabeth Witmer (Deputy Premier, Minister of Education): I'm

                    going to refer that to the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing.

 

                    Hon Chris Hodgson (Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing): I think

                    yesterday's events are tragic in the sense that a lot of people need shelter,

                    need all kinds of assistance. I know the city of Toronto is working on that

                    with their agencies, and the province of Ontario, as you heard yesterday, is

                    there to support with the homeless shelters.

 

                    In terms of the housing policy, there is good news. More than at any time in

                    history, most people are into home ownership. There are more vacancies

                    coming on-line; 40% of condos are rented. Clearly, you're talking about the

                    affordable end.

 

                    Interjections.

 

                    Hon Mr Hodgson: I'm just telling you the facts and the history. If you don't

                    want to hear the good news, if you want to concentrate on the bad news --

 

                    Interjections.

 

                    The Speaker (Hon Gary Carr): Order. The minister has the floor.

 

                    Hon Mr Hodgson: I'm trying to point out that there is some good news

                    happening in the housing industry itself. We have record numbers of people

                    being able to buy their first home. That's good news. There's still a problem

                    with affordable rents at the low end. Quite frankly, it's because of past

                    policies, where we killed the market.

 

                    We're also planning to implement the federal program. For the first time in 10

                    years, the federal government has put forward dollars for an affordable

                    housing program. We're going to participate in that and roll that out this fall.

                    There's also assistance for rent-geared-to-income subsidies, which in August,

                    if you have been following it --

 

                    The Speaker: The minister's time is up. Supplementary?

 

                    Mr Michael Prue (Beaches-East York): Minister, quite frankly the policies

                    of your government surrounding housing and a great many other things are

                    quite shameful. Your first act as a government was to slash welfare. Your

                    second act was to deregulate housing so that today in Toronto it costs about

                    $2,500 a year more to live in an apartment than it did when your government

                    deregulated housing. It's been a windfall for the landlords.

 

                    You've refused to increase ODSP for some of our most vulnerable and

                    disabled citizens. The streets are meaner. The streets are full of desperate

                    people. We have tent cities not only in Toronto, but under literally every

                    bridge and every overpass and in every ravine in every town in this province.

                    You have watched and you have done nothing but let your friends grow

                    richer.

 

                    We talked to you and we gave you a copy of our urban vision some months

                    ago, and you commented that it was a good vision and that you appreciated

                    the fact that we put it on paper. Having read it now, will you give money

                    from the land transfer tax to the municipalities to build co-ops and

                    non-profits? We're asking you right now, will you implement the provisions

                    that we gave you some months ago?

 

                    Hon Mr Hodgson: Just for the record, you talked about things that have

                    happened to drive up the cost of rent. Probably the most atrocious thing to

                    happen was what you voted for on council, to raise the taxes paid --

 

                    Interjection.

 

                    Hon Mr Hodgson: I can read the resolution for you. That translates into

                    about $200 on average for every tenant in this city, when you wanted to raise

                    the property taxes for multi-residential four and a half times higher than for

                    residential condos. That had the biggest impact.

 

                    The second thing we're not going to do is go back to the failed policies of

                    past governments. The auditor talked about a billion-dollar boondoggle. No

                    government of any responsible partisan flavour wants to go back to that. The

                    federal Liberals don't want to own the mortgages and have government doing

                    that; the provinces don't want to do it. But we do want to assist in having

                    more affordable housing built on the supply side, and that's what we're doing.

 

Back to Tent City