Tent City Eviction

Tuesday, September 24, 2002

No 1 Questions in Ontario Legislature

After TDRC spoke with Dalton McGuinty's office around noon regarding the Tent City evictions, his questions were the first questions in the day's Question Period -- It is very rare for housing or homelessness to get this prominent spot. Please find the text of his questions below. 

Debates of the Ontario Legislature (Hansard) Tuesday, September 24, 2002
ORAL QUESTIONS
HOMELESSNESS

                      Mr Dalton McGuinty (Leader of the Opposition): My first question

                    today is for the Deputy Premier. You will know that just a few hours ago

                    the police moved in and evicted the homeless people living in Toronto's

                    tent city. You will also know that your government, the Harris-Eves

                    government, walked away from its responsibility for social housing a long

                    time ago.

 

                    Government help for those with mental illness and addiction problems is

                    woefully inadequate. Shelters are at 95% capacity today, to say nothing

                    of what is going to happen during the winter months. Tell me, Madam

                    Minister, where are these people supposed to go? Who is going to help

                    them pick up their lives and re-enter society?

 

                    Hon Elizabeth Witmer (Deputy Premier, Minister of Education):

                    I'm going to refer that to the Minister of Community, Family and

                    Children's Services.

 

                    Hon Brenda Elliott (Minister of Community, Family and

                    Children's Services): I appreciate the question from my colleague

                    across the floor. As he will know full well, municipalities are responsible

                    for providing homeless shelters and things of that nature in their local

                    communities. The province is very pleased to provide the financial

                    support for that. If the city of Toronto determines that there is a need for

                    more shelter spaces, then we will do as we have always done and fund

                    these on an 80-20 cost-sharing basis.

 

                    Mr McGuinty: Thank you, Pontius Pilot. Our municipalities cannot

                    possibly cope on their own with the problems connected with our

                    homeless. They need a partner. You are supposed to be that partner.

 

                    These people are going to move to public parks, they're going to sleep

                    on sidewalks and maybe even move into people's backyards. What I

                    want to know on their behalf is, specifically, what are you and Ernie Eves

                    going to do for these people? What emergency assistance are you now

                    going to provide and what long-term solutions will you implement to

                    make sure these people get the help and the housing they need?

 

                    Hon Mrs Elliott: First of all, in an article just recently published on this,

                    Home Depot indicates, "We have worked closely with the authorities to

                    ensure that these people will have access to Toronto's social services

                    support network." So no actions were undertaken until consultations had

                    been made with the local municipality.

 

                    I would point out to my colleague across the way that already the

                    province of Ontario gives Toronto $74 million in support of homelessness

                    programs. That's just to the city of Toronto. Of course, we provide much

                    more across the province as a whole in a variety of different kinds of

                    programs and, again, if more is required, we will co-operate by sharing

                    80-20.

 

                    Mr McGuinty: Much more is required, Madam Minister, and you

                    should understand that. This is not an issue for Home Depot to address.

                    The city of Toronto cannot possibly undertake this on their own. The

                    federal government has extended a very generous offer and you refused

                    to take them up on that.

 

                    Here is your sorry record when it comes to the homeless in Ontario: you

                    gutted rent controls; you walked away from social housing; you broke

                    your promise to bring in rent subsidies; you cut funding for addiction and

                    mental health services, and you did all of this quite proudly while slashing

                    welfare rates in Ontario. Why not admit it, Madam Minister: your record

                    is absolutely shameful when it comes to lending support to some of our

                    most vulnerable and needy people.

 

                    I ask you again on their behalf, what specifically are you going to do by

                    way of emergency assistance and, then, over the long term, what are you

                    going to do to find housing and other forms of assistance for our

                    homeless?

 

                    Hon Mrs Elliott: I remind my colleague across the way that

                    homelessness is a very complex issue that requires all levels of

                    government to co-operate to find a solution.

 

                    I would remind my colleague across the way that recently Ontario

                    announced that it would donate the net proceeds from the sale of the

                    former Princess Margaret Hospital site to the city of Toronto to address

                    homelessness.

 

                    Our contribution has never been greater. Some $58 million goes to the

                    city of Toronto to help with emergency hostel service costs; $4.9 million

                    in provincial funds under the provincial homeless initiatives fund; $4.9

                    million under the emergency hostel funding program; $1.4 million for the

                    Off the Street, Into Shelter program; $3.6 million for the supports to daily

                    living programs; and just under $1 million for the community partners

                    program. We are doing our share to try and solve this very difficult and

                    very complex problem.



Back to Tent City